A History of the Walnut Hill Neighborhood in North Omaha

19th century, 20th century, 21st century, Architecture, Culture, Cuming Street, Historic houses, historic preservation, Walnut Hill

A History of the Walnut Hill Neighborhood in North Omaha

The Walnut Hill neighborhood is one of the most historically distinguished in North Omaha.

Adam F.C. Fletcher

November 28

13 minutes

As North Omaha was growing up, different areas developed at different points. The earliest neighborhood was the Near North Side. One of the first suburbs in Omaha is the Walnut Hill neighborhood.

Bounded by Cuming Street on the south, Northwest Radial Highway and Saddle Creek Road on the west, N. 40th Street on the east, and Lake Street on the north, the Walnut Hill neighborhood has a lot of unique features and a rich history.

Map of historic Walnut Hill North Omaha Nebraska — This is a map of the historic Walnut Hill neighborhood in North Omaha, including historic districts and places.

A Streetcar Suburb

Cuming Street streetcar, North Omaha, Nebraska — This is the Number 16, a streetcar that went from the railroad stations downtown, up Cuming Street to the Walnut Hill neighborhood.

In 1885, Sam Mercer, a successful doctor and real estate mogul in Omaha, developed a plan to subdivide his section of land near the Prospect Hill Cemetery. Mercer built his own massive mansion at the highest point in the neighborhood and kept his Parkview Estate intact for 20 years before he died. A majority stakeholder in Omaha’s main streetcar company, Mercer wanted his to be Omaha’s first-ever “streetcar suburb.” Running the streetcar almost directly from downtown to his development was the second amenity of Walnut Hill.

Mercer named the neighborhood after his hometown in Illinois.

The neighborhood had its own commercial district, beautiful churches, spectacular parks, and wonderful school. There were other early amenities, too: Omaha was late to pave its streets, and while most neighborhoods were only reachable on dirt, Cuming Street was “paved” almost entirely with cedar blocks as soon as Mercer opened his lots to be sold. Even better than that though, is that within five years, the length of Cuming coming uphill to Walnut Hill was covered with Galesburg brick, a fine paver used in Omaha’s most exclusive early neighborhoods.

While it was fashionable, several fine churches opened up in the neighborhood. They included Walnut Hill Methodist Episcopal Church (1888), Lowe Avenue Presbyterian Church (1906), St. Andrews Episcopal Church (1887), and others.

Sunderland Brothers Company, 1002 North 42nd Street, North Omaha, Nebraska — This is the Sunderland Brothers Company Walnut Hill Yard warehouse and delivery trucks. This building was at 1002 North 42nd Street. Its an example of the businesses located in the Walnut Hill Historic Light Industrial District.

For about 20 years starting around 1890, the Omaha Belt Line Railway was also an important transportation factor for Walnut Hill. Designed to provide higher speed, more direct access to the entire city for residents throughout the city, the Belt Line cut straight through the neighborhood. This allowed its residents to take leisurely rides through the city’s extreme outskirts, and gave many people connections to other neighborhoods they would’ve never seen otherwise.

Through example, intention and power, Mercer grew one of Omaha’s most important suburbs early in city history. It had all the right people, all the best homes, and many of the city’s best features. Here’s a short history of the neighborhood.

Cuming Street pavement, North Omaha, Nebraska — Galesburg brick pavers like these once paved Cuming Street from downtown Omaha to the Walnut Hill neighborhood, thanks to Samuel Mercer.

Mercer Mansion

The first amenity was the crown jewel of the entire community for a long time. Mercer had his own twenty-three room Queen Anne mansion built on the top of Walnut Hill for all to see as they crested the hill on the streetcar. It is located at 3902 Cuming Street.

Built in 1885, this spectacular home is a large, rambling beauty sits on an entire city block. Its ornate brick exterior is unusual and features a lot of peaks and indentations, making the eyeballs pop when you’re trying to take in the whole house. On the corner of the mansion, large 4 story tower told everyone how important the home was to the neighborhood, while the placement of the mansion told everyone how important Mercer was to the entire city.

Inside his home, Mercer built a modern house fit for a king. Cherry, mahogany, oak and black walnut woodwork fills every nook and cranny. Fine moldings, built-in cabinetry and stunning banisters on the staircases make the home spectacular in every way. Originally, there were butler’s rooms and plenty of space for guests. It was stellar.

Learn more about the Mercer Mansion »

J. B. Mason House

Local architect J.B. Mason built 4025 Izard, in 1890, just four years after the Mercer Mansion was finished, and just a few houses away. According to myomahaobsession.com, there are “20 or more rooms” with 21 different kinds of wood throughout the house. Home to an eclectic hospital for several decades, there are also “many fireplaces faced with pottery from Holland.” Perhaps the most spectacular detail to this house isn’t indoors at all though. Instead, its in the backyard. The longtime owner of that period, an eccentric doctor, built a grand castle and virtual fairyland in the backyard. I highly recommend the myomahaobsession article about the property.

Neely House

The Neely House at 4371 Hamilton St in the Walnut Hill neighborhood was built in 1905, and today it has almost 3,400 square feet, sitting on 1/3 acre of land. The house was built for Henry David Neely, who was in the insurance industry and was president of the Nebraska Life Underwriters’ Association. Born in 1851, he was trained as a lawyer and moved to Omaha in 1891. His wife, Emma, was involved throughout the community, including with the Omaha Women’s Club and the Ornithological Society. They were members at the Lowe Avenue Presbyterian Church, which was at N. 40th and Nicholas (the building is still there). Today, the Neely House is subdivided into apartments.

Other Significant Homes and Buildings

W. Stein Building, North 40th and Hamilton Street, North Omaha, Nebraska — This 1880s block at N. 40th and Hamilton Streets in the Walnut Hill neighborhood includes a former theatre and more.

The Stein block at North 40th and Hamilton Streets has been the subject of ongoing renovations by John Hargiss. Currently, the former bakery on the corner has been restored as a string instrument shop, and the 40th Street Theater has been reopened as a performance and rental space.

Omar's Bakery, Walnut Hill neighborhood, North Omaha, Nebraska — An Omar’s Bakery delivery man with his wagon in the 1910s outside the Omar Bakery in the Walnut Hill neighborhood.

Located on the other side of the neighborhood, the Omar Baking Company was located at North 43th and Nicholas Streets. The company delivered bakery products to neighborhoods around the city through much of the 20th century using horse-drawn wagons and trucks. This facility ran from 1923 through the 1960s. As for fine homes, Mercer’s wasn’t the only one on Walnut Hill. Instead, the entire neighborhood is packed with fine, large homes and kinda glamorous apartments. The City of Omaha has noted that the following homes and buildings are architecturally important:

903, 925 and 1023 Mercer Blvd
912, 1010 and 1026 Mercer Park Road
3415 and 4371 Hamilton Street
3110, 4125, and 4383 Nicholas Street
3019, 3130, 3205, 3219, 3419, 3423, 3514, 3647, and 4024 Lafayette Avenue
4504 Cuming Street
4009, 4012, 4016, 4025, 4106, 4113, 4128
4517 Izard Street

Samuel Mercer was also responsible for platting the opulent Bemis Park neighborhood, which is next to the Walnut Hill neighborhood.

Modern Omaha designer Quentin Lueninghoener has shared with me extensive information about Sidney Smith (1839-1915), the architect who designed Dr. Mercer’s fine home. Apparently, Smith was hired to design many of the homes in the Walnut Hill neighborhood after his work for Dr. Mercer. Most exciting to me is that they vary in size and opulence. Some of them are huge and ornate while others are small and simple—but there are mixes in-between too, with small ornate houses and large simple homes. Following are some of the Sidney Smith-designed houses still standing in Walnut Hill:

1112 North 40th Street (1885)
4010 Nicholas Street (1885)
4012 Nicholas Street (1885)
4014 Nicholas Street (1885)
J. T. Stuart House, 4130 Nicholas Street (1885)
4024 Nicholas Street (c.1886)
4102 Nicholas Street (c.1886)
4112 Nicholas Street (c.1886)
4116 Nicholas Street (c.1886)
4120 Nicholas Street (c.1886)
4124 Nicholas Street (c.1886)
4128 Nicholas Street (c.1886)
4201 Lafayette Street (c.1886)
4207 Lafayette Street (c.1886)
4211 Lafayette Street (c.1886)
4215 Lafayette Street (c.1886)
4019 Lafayette Street (c.1886)
4022 Lafayette Street (c.1886)
4023 Lafayette Street (c.1886)

Additionally, Sidney Smith is credited with designing more than 25 other houses throughout the neighborhood in 1885 and 1886. He was very influential in what is standing throughout the Walnut Hill neighborhood today.

The Reservoir Wonderland

Walnut Hill Reservoir, North Omaha, Nebraska — The beautiful wonderland of Walnut Hill Reservoir was a retreat for all of Omaha for more than 75 years.

The second amenity in his Mercer’s neighborhood is the Walnut Hill Reservoir. Built in 1885 as part of the original Omaha Water Works, the reservoir was improved and maintained for years as a wonderland in a suburban oasis.

The reservoir has three basins that hold about 22,000,000 gallons of water to help quench the thirst of this part of North Omaha, and a huge pumping station moving all that water around. More importantly though, its a lavish park made with a long sidewalk, an observation point that used to look out over the Missouri River Valley, and a glorious fountain. In its day, the park also had glorious lighting, letting lovers and families enjoy the ambience outdoors.

Learn more about the history of the Walnut Hill Reservoir »

Mercer Park

The neighborhood is also home to the Mercer Park, which is a pretty slice of land that the family donated to the City of Omaha in memory of Caroline Mercer, Samuel’s daughter, after she died in a trans-Atlantic ship sinking. Eleven acres were given to the City in 1910 on the condition they extend Lincoln Boulevard into the park to connect it through the Reservoir’s parkland, with the goal of tying it to the John Creighton Boulevard several blocks away.

The City followed through on part of their deal, which is evident in the funky little driveway along Cuming Street north of N. 38th Street – that was part of the deal. However, the City has long since closed down the Park Drive through the Reservoir’s parkland, and they never connected it to Creighton Boulevard.

Walnut Hill Elementary School

Walnut Hill School 4383 Hamilton Street North Omaha Nebraska — This is a design and construction photo of the Walnut Hill School as it appeared in 1926.

Built in 1926, the Walnut Hill Elementary School at 4355 Charles Street was seen as a vital institution for the neighborhood that reflected its important place in the city’s culture. Originally opened soon after the neighborhood was established, the first school building opened in 1888. Mercer himself donated the land for the building, which included the large grove of black walnut trees the hill was named for.

The Walnut Hill car number 171 in the 1890s. It traveled from downtown Omaha up Cuming Street to North 40th Street.

According to Omaha Public Schools, the building has been renovated four times since: once in 1953, again in 1964, 1985 and again in 2004. Ten new classrooms were added that year, and in 2015 the building has 405 student. The school is racially diverse, and there is a large program for English language learners. The percentage of students qualifying for and receiving free and reduced lunch is 98%.

Methodist Hospital

Founded in another part of Omaha, in 1908 the Methodist Hospital built a grand 100-plus bed facility that opened at 3612 Cuming Street on Walnut Hill. They surely did this because of the prestige of the address and the ease of getting there via Mercer’s streetcar service.

The Methodist Episcopal Hospital and Deaconess’ Home Association started in 1891. Focused exclusively on opening a hospital, the Methodists’ first hospital was opened at St. Mary’s Avenue and S. 20th Street.

In 1908, they moved their facility to 3612 Cuming Street which had 128 beds in the middle part of the building pictured above. They remained on Walnut Hill until 1968, when the moved the main hospital to west Omaha. Rebranding the Cuming Street location as Methodist Midtown Hospital, it stayed open through the 1980s, when the Salvation Army took over the facility.

In 2016, the Salvation Army demolished this historical edifice to make room for a new building.

The Future of Walnut Hill

North 40th and Hamilton, North Omaha, Nebraska — The intersection of N. 40th and Hamilton included a gas station, Martin’s Donuts, a grocery, and the Walnut Hill Reservoir.

Walnut Hill is not a simple neighborhood. Instead, its packed with contradictions and anomalies that make it one of Omaha’s most dynamic neighborhoods. Well-deserving of any preservation effort foisted upon it, the City of Omaha seems just as likely to deny it its vital role as every other neighborhood in North Omaha. Rather than lavish it with praise and reinforcing its identity, media does no favors.

Instead, just like the rest of the North Omaha community, its up to Walnut Hill to embrace its history, to carve out its identity and to reinforce the important role it has played in the past and can have in the future. That’s is one way its like every other neighborhood in the community. Another way is through the influx of newness happening there: Whereas once the neighborhood was wealthy and white, today there are new populations of diversity and ability. Young immigrant families, long-established African American families and others are moving into Walnut Hill and throughout the area where the neighborhood sits. As the section above about Walnut Hill illustrates, there’s newness all about this area.

So the future of Walnut Hill belongs to the residents of Walnut Hill. If the City of Omaha won’t step up, people in the neighborhood should step up for the neighborhood. Its neighboring institutions are trying to, including St. Cecelia and St. Augustine, and the Walnut Hill School.

What are YOU doing for Walnut Hill today?!?

You Might Like…

Bonus Pics!

Phillips 66, North 40th and Hamilton Street, North Omaha, Nebraska — This is the Phillips 66 gas station at North 40th and Hamilton, pictured in the 1950s. Opening as a White Rose station in the 1910s, it was replaced and the lot is now part of a Tesaro gas station. Photo courtesy of Michelle Kotrc Jud.

Park Drive, North Omaha, Nebraska — In 1926, this wet scene in Mercer Park included trees, sidewalks, and street lamps lining the Mercer Park Drive in the Walnut Hill Neighborhood.

Mercer Mansion, N. 39th and Cuming Streets, North Omaha, Nebraska — The Mercer Mansion at N. 39th and Cuming Streets in 1906.

Mercer Mansion, North 40th and Cuming Streets, North Omaha, Nebraska — These are shots taken of the interior of the Mercer Mansion in 1963, after it was divided into apartments.

Methodist Episcopal Hospital, 923 North 38th Street in the Bemis Park neighborhood, North Omaha, Nebraska — This is the original Nebraska Methodist Hospital at 923 North 38th Street on the edge of the Walnut Hill neighborhood.

St. Cecilia Church, 4114 Hamilton Street, North Omaha, Nebraska — The St. Cecilia Parish opened in 1894, and this pic is from 1904 copy of the Omaha World-Herald. Apparently it was demolished by a windstorm in 1917.

Discover more from NorthOmahaHistory.com—People, places and events from the history of North Omaha, Nebraska by Adam Fletcher Sasse

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

13 responses to “A History of the Walnut Hill Neighborhood in North Omaha”

Kathleen Dovel

December 10, 2016 at 6:17 pm

Thank you for this web sight. I grew up on 45th and Hamilton and went to Walnut Hill School all 8 years. My parents lived in their house till my Mother died in 2005 at 97 yrs old. My dad wanted to stay so my sisters and I kept the house and took turns having him stay at our houses and he liked that. He died in 2007 just three months before his 100th birthday. He worked at the Weathercraft Roofing Company all those years before retirement. It was just around the corner from Omar Bakery. He bought the house next door when it was for sale and my husband died and I needed a place to live. So my kids went to Walnut Hill also until I married again. They were in 3rd and 4th grade. Oh so many memories. I could write a book!!! My niece moved into the house I lived in and still lives there. She also bought some other properties in the area and rents them out. Her son lives in our parents house. My Dad was Vern F Goodrich. We walked everyplace we went back in the 40’s. Thanks for letting me share!!!

Reply
1. Carol Cronin
  
  April 26, 2017 at 12:26 am
  
  I always love your articles. However, Caroline “Carrie” Mercer did not perish in a “trans-Atlantic ship sinking”. In fact, she ‘fell’ overboard on the USS Minneapolis about 20 miles off the coast of New York en route to England with her brother Nelson, his wife, and their sister Mary. Legend has it that she was in love with an English Clergyman but her love was not returned. There is a beautiful portrait of her in the mansion.
  
  Here is an article from the NY Sun.: http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn83030272/1911-09-05/ed-1/seq-3/#date1=1911&index=2&rows=20&words=Caroline+Mercer&searchType=basic&sequence=0&state=&date2=1911&proxtext=%22Caroline+Mercer%22&y=0&x=0&dateFilterType=yearRange&page=1
  
  Here is an article in the Omaha Daily Bee: http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn83030272/1911-09-05/ed-1/seq-3/#date1=1911&index=2&rows=20&words=Caroline+Mercer&searchType=basic&sequence=0&state=&date2=1911&proxtext=%22Caroline+Mercer%22&y=0&x=0&dateFilterType=yearRange&page=1
  
  ALSO, this obituary about Dr. Mercer is fascinating. http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn99021999/1907-10-11/ed-1/seq-1/#date1=1905&index=10&rows=20&words=death+Mercer&searchType=basic&sequence=0&state=&date2=1922&proxtext=Mercer+death&y=0&x=0&dateFilterType=yearRange&page=1
  and: http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn99021999/1907-10-11/ed-1/seq-2/#date1=1907&index=6&rows=20&words=Mercer+MERCER&searchType=basic&sequence=0&state=Nebraska&date2=1907&proxtext=mercer&y=0&x=0&dateFilterType=yearRange&page=1
  
  Reply
  1. Adam Fletcher
    
    April 26, 2017 at 1:28 am
    
    Thanks for your enthusiastic response Carol! I’ll edit the article with what you’ve shared. At some point I need to write a bio on ol’ Doc Mercer himself!
Historic Neighborhoods – North Omaha History

January 31, 2017 at 4:21 pm

[…] Article: History of Walnut Hill […]

Reply
Benson Motor Company – North Omaha History

March 4, 2017 at 2:09 pm

[…] Walnut Hill […]

Reply
Historical Tour of North Omaha – North Omaha History

March 10, 2017 at 9:21 pm

[…] North Omaha History article: A History of the Walnut Hill Neighborhood […]

Reply
Streetcars in North Omaha – North Omaha History

March 15, 2017 at 4:48 pm

[…] in Ames Avenue, Fort Street, and other commercial areas along N. 16th, N. 24th and N. 30th Streets. Walnut Hill, Benson, Dundee, and several western neighborhoods in North Omaha were also served for the first […]

Reply
Carol Pinard Cronin

January 27, 2019 at 6:03 am

Carolyn Mercer didn’t die in a ship sinking….she died after falling/jumping overboard right after the ship had left New York. she was traveling with Nelson, her brother. would love to share more about this and a little more about Mercer. I currently live in the little carriage house on the property and did a lot of personal research.

Reply
1. Adam F. C. Fletcher
  
  January 27, 2019 at 10:11 pm
  
  I would love that Carol! Send anything you want to info@northomahahistory.com — including writing, pics, anything — and I’ll credit you massively! Thanks for sharing!
  
  Reply
SynCallio

October 26, 2020 at 6:53 pm

Nice to see this! I grew up in Walnut Hill: we lived in the modest Queen Anne at 4509 Seward. Which is now the home of the owners of Amateur Coffee! Though we left Walnut Hill back in 1990, we kept in touch with the neighbors as long as we could.

Reply
1. JUDY O
  
  August 28, 2023 at 7:27 pm
  
  My family and I lived in that same house from1990 until 2008. Daughters went to St. Cecilia’s.
  
  Reply
Elvin Addy

November 2, 2022 at 8:34 pm

I graduated from Walnut Hill (49-50 class. School was on Hamilton st. Not Charles st. I lived at 4518 Hamilton.
Enjoyed the memories .

Reply
1. Sharon G.
  
  April 22, 2023 at 5:41 pm
  
  Elvin, how exciting to see your name on here. How are you doing? And also Melvin. I was so thrilled that you came to our parents 70th anniversary, and haven’t seen you since. I always tell people that we were twins living next door to twins when we were growing up. We couldn’t have had better neighbors.😀
  
  Reply

A History of the Walnut Hill Neighborhood in North Omaha

A Streetcar Suburb